Are Military Courts Needed in Ukraine: Human Rights Center Analyzes Legal Protections
The «Pryncyp» human rights center has analyzed the initiative to restore military justice, explaining why creating separate military courts will not solve servicemen's problems.
🚨EventsPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- «Pryncyp» analyzed the proposal to restore military justice.
- Military-judges could face undue influence from military command.
- Experts suggest specialized civilian judges instead of separate courts.
Discussions regarding the restoration of the military justice system have intensified amid the full-scale war, drawing the attention of parliamentary committees and the public. Proponents of these changes often argue that military personnel cases should be handled exclusively by those with actual army service experience. However, the «Pryncyp» human rights center for servicemen has criticized the idea of reviving separate military courts and prosecutor's offices.
Why Military Courts Pose Risks to Judicial Independence
The primary argument in favor of military courts is that civilian judges allegedly cannot fully understand the specifics of military service. At the same time, experts point out that if judges receive military ranks, it creates a direct dependency on the Ministry of Defense or the General Staff. Such a system would undermine the fundamental principle of judicial independence, as military-judges would be subject to military statutes and chain-of-command discipline.
«For a serviceman whose case is being reviewed, all this means a risk that the decision will be influenced by the command vertical rather than the law and the circumstances of the case», — the human rights center emphasizes.
Furthermore, holding a military rank or having combat experience does not automatically guarantee deep legal knowledge or objectivity. Throughout the full-scale war, Ukrainian civilian courts have already accumulated significant practice in handling such cases. Whenever specialized knowledge is required, the law allows for the involvement of relevant experts and professional evaluations.
An Alternative Path: Specialization Instead of Isolation
Instead of building a separate military court system, which would be extremely difficult to implement currently, «Pryncyp» advocates for introducing judicial specialization within the existing system. This involves focusing on crimes against the established order of military service and military administrative offenses. Such an approach aligns with European standards and enhances the quality of court decisions without compromising judicial independence.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
🎓EducationFire on Russian Vessel Sparta II in the Gulf of Finland Continues Following Drone Attack
Efforts to extinguish the fire on the Russian cargo ship Sparta II are ongoing in Finnish territorial waters.
Nighttime Drone Attack on Dymer: Rescuers Search for Missing Residents After Apartment Hit
A 14-story apartment building in Dymer, Kyiv region, was partially destroyed following a hostile drone attack, leaving 14 people unreachable.
🎓EducationSlavyansk under attack: consequences of massive shelling and evacuation in Donetsk region
As a result of enemy strikes on Slavyansk and other settlements in the Donetsk region, civilians were injured, and authorities continue to rescue people from dangerous ar…
⚽SportUkrainian tennis players Svitolina and Kostyuk nominated for prestigious WTA awards
Elina Svitolina and Marta Kostyuk have been nominated for the Women's Tennis Association annual awards following a successful season.
Monumental Tombs from the Era of King Herod Discovered in Palestine
Archaeologists have found three ancient burial complexes near Jericho dating back to the reign of King Herod, containing rare wooden and textile artifacts.
🛡️SecurityStrike on residential building in Kyiv region: 14 people missing
A Russian drone strike partially destroyed the entrance of a five-story building in Dymytrivka/Dymer, Kyiv region, as rescue operations continue.